While real estate property ownership is not correlated to the
U.S. equity markets as represented by the S&P 500 index,
buying individual properties for one’s investment portfolio
offers significant challenges. However, investments in real
estate-related securities, such as Real Estate Investment Trusts
(REITs) offer significantly more flexibility. REITs are
publicly-traded securities issued by companies that invest in
investment grade institutional properties. REITs are
pass-through entities for income tax purposes as long as they
pay out a minimum of 90% of their profits to shareholders every
year. The last four years of REIT performance have been
spectacular especially in comparison to the rough years of 1998
and 1999. Their long- term outlook of their dividend stream
causes them to look attractive. Before investing in REITs, one
must understand the fundamentals and how they can be an integral
part of a diversified portfolio.
REITs are total return investments, offering high dividends
typically 5% to 6% in today’s environment and the potential
for moderate, long-term capital appreciation. REITs, due to the
stable nature of the revenue source, are not high growth type
investments. In a diversified portfolio REITs provide a pattern
of return that is dissimilar with other investments in the
portfolio while potentially providing a long-term total return
equivalent to equities.
REIT Benefits:
Investing in REITs offer a number of benefits, especially
REIT Mutual Funds (probably the best way to invest in them).
Some of the benefits include:
- REIT returns have performed better (11.57% as represented
by The Wilshire REIT Index) than the S&P 500 since the
beginning of 1994 thru September 30, 2003 (generally
considered the modern era of REITs) with approximately 20%
less risk (The Wilshire REIT has a 14.03 standard deviation
over the last ten years versus 17.37 standard deviation for
the S&P 500).
- REITs have high dividends – currently 5% to 6%. These
are fully taxable and not subject to the special 15% tax
rate, which was enacted in 2003. Occasionally, additional
cash distributions are made that are non-taxable. These are
called return of capital for income tax purposes, which
actually reduce your cost basis leading to a larger capital
gain when you sell. Capital gains are now taxed at a minimum
income tax rate of 15.0%
- REITs have relatively strong balance sheets due to
moderate levels of debt (typically 50% of less of the asset
levels).
- REITs have experienced, professional real estate managers.
The securities are also overseen by the SEC.
- REITs have low relative correlation (a similar pattern of
performance) to broad market indices such as the S&P
500, Nasdaq Composite and the Russell 2000 (typically REITs
move similar to these asset classes approximately 30% of the
time or less)
REIT Risks:
REITs are also subject to risks such as recession risk,
property damage and security threats, pricing problems,
liability lawsuits, bad management, overbuilding, etc. There are
other unique risks specific to REITs:
- In past years when discussions about changing the income
taxation features of REITs have occurred, prices of these
securities have sometimes dropped significantly.
- REITs, on average, are not as reliant on debt as they were
in the 1980s. The average debt load is now approximately
50%. However, some are heavily in debt. Also, variable rate
debt can cause significant financial problems as interest
rates rise.
Parting Thoughts:
REITs have many positive attributes and they will enhance any
portfolio long-term performance in terms of reducing its
volatility and will perhaps increase its returns. Despite the
fact that these investments have appreciated so much over the
past four years, due to their dividends, they should deliver a
total return better than large U.S. equities as represented by
the S&P 500 (which is still grossly overvalued) over the
next three to five years.